It's really hard to compare active trinkets (ZHM, VT, etc) to passive trinkets (DFT, BB, etc) using some reasonable basis. Quality can only be compared when you can quantify their effects and that's what I've been trying to attempt.
Drake Fang Talisman
Listing the DPS for DFT for comparison basis. Since I am trying to use Excel spreadsheet to model DPS, I am going to do it in lazy mode by simply adding 2% hit and 56ap to my model and take the difference in DPS.
With my current set-up, DFT contributes about 11.5 DPS.Hand of Justice
Listing the DPS for HoJ becuase this trinket is generally being overvalued by the public. "2% chance on hit to gain 1 extra attack" is extremely similar to +2% hit. Yes, 2% hit to gain 1 extra attack is slightly better. No, the difference is not material to use different numbers for either of them.
Earthstrike
Use: Increases your melee and ranged attack power by 280. Effect lasts for 20 sec.Since I am trying to use Excel spreadsheet to model DPS, I am going to do it in lazy mode. Calculating each individual attack's benefit from ES is a major pita and varies dramatically depending on specs.
DPS = Damage Dealt / Time
= (Total DPS after +280 Attack Power - Total Original DPS) * 20 / (120 for sustained, 20 for burst)
~ 6.6 DPS sustained~ 39.8 DPS burst, according to my gear set-upAnother method of calculation is to pro-rate it to its cooldown. So +280 attack power for 20 seconds every 2 minutes can be scaled into 47 attack power over 2 minutes.
So Earthstrike can be treated as a 47 attack power trinket for sustained damage purposes.
Renataki's Charm of Trickery
Use: Instantly increases your energy by 60.DPS = Average Backstab Hit / (Trinket Cooldown for Sustained)
= 1000 / 180
=
5.6 DPSThe Burst DPS for Renataki's Charm of Trickery is meaningless due to its instant nature. 1000 damage / 1 second = 1000 DPS anyone?
Venomous Totem
Use: Increases the chance to apply Rogue poisons to your target by 30% for 20 sec.Simple and straight forward calculation
DPS = Total # of Landing Hits * 30% * Poison Damage / (Trinket Cooldown for Sustained | 20 Second for Burst)
= { [(Activating Energy + 20*10)/(Hemo 35 | SS 40 | BS 60) * 30% * (130 | 150 Viled Poison) * [100% - max(5% - Hit Rate, 0)] + [(20/MH Weapon Speed) + (20/OH Weapon Speed)] * 30% * (130 | 150 Viled Poison) * [100% - max(24% - Hit Rate, 0)] } / (300 | 20)
Example: Assuming 1.8 Speed MH, 1.6 Speed OH, 5% hit, Backstab and duel wield Instant Poison VI with no Viel Poison talent and activate trinket at full (100) energy.
VT Sustained DPS = [5 * 0.3 * 130 + (11.11 + 12.5) * 0.3 * 130 * 0.81]/300 =
3.1VT Burst DPS = [5 * 0.3 * 130 + (11.11 + 12.5) * 0.3 * 130 * 0.81]/20 =
47.1Zandalarian Hero Medallion
Use: Increases your melee and ranged damage by 40 for 20 sec. Every time you hit a target, this bonus is reduced by 2.Worst active trinket to proximate DPS. Period.
However, I am a lazy fuck and I adhere to KISS principle, so here is the very proximate evaluation of ZHM:
Total Damage Added ~ [(1+20)*10/2]*2 = 210
Total Damage Added after Crit/Hit Effects ~ 210 * [(1 - Miss Rate + Hit Rate) + 2 * Crit Rate)]
Assuming 5% Hit and 27% Crit
Total Damage Added after Crit/Hit Effects = 281.4
DPS = 281.4 / (20 for burst, 120 for sustained) =
14.1 burst DPS or 2.3 sustained DPSSince this method ignores special attacks and all the talent perks, I will give it a 2x ratio to make it
28.2 burst DPS or 4.6 sustained DPS.
